When I was young I loved to fish. In my hometown, there was a reservoir. It was Indianapolis’s water supply. All through grade school and middle school, I fished along its banks as often as I could. Every once and a while, my stepdad took me out in his skiff, and we’d fish the little inlets along the north end of the reservoir. This was before they started building lake houses and people started claiming ownership of the shoreline.
We’d also run trout lines, but often, especially after my...